S&P 500 (SPX) Returns Breakdown 1917 to 1999: Terry Smith Shows Only 2.3% Came From P/E Expansion, Earnings Drove the Rest | Flash News Detail | Blockchain.News
Latest Update
1/31/2026 10:56:00 AM

S&P 500 (SPX) Returns Breakdown 1917 to 1999: Terry Smith Shows Only 2.3% Came From P/E Expansion, Earnings Drove the Rest

S&P 500 (SPX) Returns Breakdown 1917 to 1999: Terry Smith Shows Only 2.3% Came From P/E Expansion, Earnings Drove the Rest

According to @QCompounding citing Terry Smith, buying the S&P 500 at a price to earnings of 5.3 and selling at 34 would have delivered about 11.6% annualized, with only roughly 2.3 percentage points from multiple expansion (source: @QCompounding). This decomposition indicates most long-term equity returns came from earnings growth and reinvestment rather than rerating (source: @QCompounding). For portfolio positioning, prioritize companies with durable earnings compounding, strong reinvestment, and high return on capital, and be cautious about relying on valuation multiple expansion for alpha (source: @QCompounding). For index exposure, expected returns will hinge more on forward earnings trajectories and capital allocation than on further rerating (source: @QCompounding). Near term, focus on earnings revisions, buybacks, and dividend growth as key total-return drivers rather than multiple swings (source: @QCompounding).

Source

Analysis

Understanding the historical performance of the S&P 500 offers valuable lessons for cryptocurrency traders navigating volatile markets like Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH). According to a insightful quote from investor Terry Smith, shared by @QCompounding, if you invested in the S&P 500 at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 5.3x back in 1917 and sold at 34x in 1999, your annual return would have reached 11.6%. Remarkably, only 2.3% per annum stemmed from the dramatic P/E expansion, while the bulk came from companies' earnings growth and reinvestments. This narrative underscores a timeless trading principle: sustainable returns in equities and crypto alike often hinge on fundamental growth rather than speculative valuation spikes.

Applying S&P 500 Lessons to Crypto Trading Strategies

In the cryptocurrency space, this historical insight resonates deeply amid ongoing market fluctuations. For instance, Bitcoin's price has seen massive expansions in valuation metrics, similar to P/E ratios in stocks, but long-term holders have benefited more from network adoption and on-chain activity than short-term hype. Consider BTC's realized capitalization, a metric akin to earnings in traditional finance, which has grown steadily from under $100 billion in 2017 to over $500 billion as of recent data points. Traders focusing on these fundamentals could identify buying opportunities during dips, such as when BTC traded around $30,000 in mid-2021, yielding substantial returns as it climbed to $60,000 by late that year. Ethereum, with its transition to proof-of-stake in September 2022, mirrors corporate reinvestments through staking rewards, potentially driving annual yields of 4-6% for holders, far outpacing mere price speculation.

Cross-Market Correlations and Institutional Flows

Linking this to broader market dynamics, institutional investors are increasingly viewing cryptocurrencies as digital assets with earnings-like potential through decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols. Data from sources like Chainalysis reports indicate that institutional flows into BTC and ETH surged by 120% in 2023, correlating with S&P 500 recoveries post-2022 bear markets. For traders, this suggests monitoring correlation coefficients; BTC's 30-day correlation with the S&P 500 hovered around 0.6 in early 2024, implying that positive stock earnings reports could bolster crypto sentiment. Trading pairs like BTC/USD on exchanges show volume spikes during U.S. market hours, with average daily volumes exceeding $20 billion, providing liquidity for strategies that capitalize on these ties. Moreover, resistance levels for BTC around $70,000, as seen in November 2024 timestamps, often align with S&P 500 peaks, offering short-term selling signals while emphasizing long-term hold strategies based on 'earnings' from mining rewards and transaction fees.

Delving deeper into trading opportunities, this S&P 500 example encourages crypto investors to prioritize metrics like total value locked (TVL) in ETH-based DeFi, which ballooned from $10 billion in 2020 to over $100 billion by 2024, driving real yield generation. Unlike the 1917-1999 stock period, crypto's shorter history amplifies volatility, but patterns emerge: during the 2022 crypto winter, ETH's price dropped 70%, yet on-chain metrics like daily active addresses remained resilient, foreshadowing a rebound to $4,000 by March 2024. Savvy traders might use tools like moving averages; the 200-day MA for BTC provided support at $25,000 in June 2023, aligning with broader market reinvestment themes. Institutional adoption, evidenced by BlackRock's ETF inflows surpassing $10 billion in Q1 2024, further validates this approach, suggesting that focusing on 'earnings' from blockchain utility could yield compounded returns similar to the 11.6% annual figure in stocks.

Risk Management and Long-Term Outlook

For risk-averse traders, integrating these insights means diversifying across assets with strong fundamental growth. Altcoins like Solana (SOL), boasting transaction speeds that enhance 'earnings' through fees, have shown 24-hour trading volumes of $2 billion during peak periods in 2024, correlating with S&P 500 tech sector gains. However, risks abound; regulatory shifts, such as potential SEC rulings on ETH staking, could mimic historical stock market corrections. Overall, this historical perspective from Terry Smith highlights that while P/E-like expansions in crypto can boost short-term gains, true wealth accumulation stems from underlying value creation, urging traders to analyze on-chain data for informed decisions rather than chasing fleeting pumps.

Compounding Quality

@QCompounding

🏰 Quality Stocks 🧑‍💼 Former Professional Investor ➡️ Teaching people about investing on our website.